The Top 10 Toasters to Buy in 2025
Introduction
In 2025, the humble toaster remains a kitchen essential, evolving with new features, smarter controls, and eye-catching designs. Whether you crave perfectly browned sourdough, crispy bagels, or quick frozen waffles, today’s toasters offer something for every breakfast lover. After reviewing expert opinions, consumer feedback, and rigorous testing from sources like Consumer Reports and Bon Appétit, here’s a comprehensive guide to the best toasters you can buy this year.
Why a Quality Toaster Still Matters
Despite the rise of multifunctional countertop appliances, a dedicated toaster excels at one thing: delivering consistently perfect toast. The best models offer:
- Consistent Browning: Even results across all slices, batch after batch.
- Versatility: Handling everything from thick bagels to delicate pastries.
- User-Friendly Controls: Intuitive dials, digital displays, and smart features.
- Durability & Design: Sturdy construction and styles to match any kitchen.
- Helpful Extras: Wide slots, high-lift levers, and easy-to-clean crumb trays.
For more on choosing the right kitchen tech, see our guides to the top 10 streaming devices for home entertainment in 2025 and the top 10 Bluetooth speakers to buy in 2025.
The Top 10 Toasters for 2025
Below are the standout models, blending expert recommendations and real-world performance:
1. Breville BTA720XL “A Bit More” 2-Slice Toaster
- Why it stands out: The “A Bit More” button lets you add extra time without restarting. Sleek stainless steel, LED progress indicator, and motorized lift make it a tech lover’s favorite.
- Price Range: $150–$200
- Best For: Precision toasting, tech enthusiasts
2. Cuisinart CPT-415 Countdown Metal 2-Slice
- Why it stands out: Digital countdown timer, multiple shade settings, and wide slots for bagels or thick bread. Consistently ranks high for reliability.
- Price Range: $80–$120
- Best For: Busy mornings, precision toasting
3. Beautiful by Drew Barrymore 2-Slice Toaster
- Why it stands out: Stylish, compact, and available in trendy colors. The glass window lets you watch your toast brown.
- Price Range: $60–$90
- Best For: Style-conscious buyers, small kitchens
4. Smeg 50s Retro Style 2-Slice Toaster
- Why it stands out: Iconic retro design, robust build, and six browning levels. A statement piece for any countertop.
- Price Range: $180–$220
- Best For: Design enthusiasts, durability
5. Breville Smart Toaster 4-Slice
- Why it stands out: Smart controls, motorized lift, and customizable settings for families with varied toasting needs.
- Price Range: $200+
- Best For: Large households, tech-savvy users
6. Hamilton Beach Keep Warm 4-Slice Toaster
- Why it stands out: “Keep warm” setting, extra-wide slots, and independent controls for each pair of slots. Great for families.
- Price Range: $25–$40
- Best For: Families, versatility
7. KitchenAid KMT422OB 4-Slice Toaster
- Why it stands out: Durable, even toasting, high-lift lever, and removable crumb tray. Matches KitchenAid’s iconic mixer line.
- Price Range: $100–$140
- Best For: Heavy users, artisan bread lovers
8. BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster
- Why it stands out: Budget-friendly, wide slots, and simple controls. Reliable performance for everyday use.
- Price Range: $20–$35
- Best For: Budget buyers, small spaces
9. Dualit NewGen 2-Slice Toaster
- Why it stands out: Hand-built in the UK, replaceable parts, and classic design. Built to last for years.
- Price Range: $200–$250
- Best For: Longevity, craftsmanship
10. Oster 2-Slice Touchscreen Toaster
- Why it stands out: Modern touchscreen interface, seven shade settings, and minimalist design.
- Price Range: $50–$70
- Best For: Modern kitchens, tech fans
Comparison Table
| Model | Slices | Key Feature | Price Range | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Breville BTA720XL | 2 | “A Bit More” button | $$$ | Tech lovers |
| Cuisinart CPT-415 | 2 | Countdown timer | $$ | Precision toasting |
| Beautiful by Drew Barrymore | 2 | Glass window | $$ | Style seekers |
| Smeg 50s Retro Style | 2 | Retro design | $$$$ | Design enthusiasts |
| Breville Smart Toaster | 4 | Smart controls | $$$$ | Large households |
| Hamilton Beach Keep Warm | 4 | Keep warm setting | $ | Families |
| KitchenAid KMT422OB | 4 | High-lift lever | $$$ | Artisan bread lovers |
| BLACK+DECKER Extra Wide Slot | 2 | Wide slots | $ | Budget buyers |
| Dualit NewGen | 2 | Repairable design | $$$$ | Longevity |
| Oster Touchscreen | 2 | Touchscreen | $ | Modern kitchens |
What to Look for When Shopping
- Slot Size: Wide and long slots accommodate bagels and artisan loaves.
- Number of Slots: 2-slice for singles/couples, 4-slice for families.
- Special Features: Bagel, defrost, reheat, and keep-warm settings.
- Design: Choose a style that matches your kitchen decor.
- Budget: Toasters range from under $20 to over $200—prioritize features that matter most.
For more kitchen tech inspiration, see our guides to the top 10 toasters for every kitchen in 2025 and top 10 smart TVs under $1000 in 2025.
Maintenance Tips
Pro Tip: Regularly empty the crumb tray and wipe down the exterior to keep your toaster running smoothly and safely.
Conclusion
The perfect toaster for 2025 balances performance, features, and price with your specific needs. Whether you’re drawn to the retro charm of a Smeg, the tech-forward Breville, or a budget-friendly Hamilton Beach, there’s a model here for every kitchen and lifestyle. For more in-depth reviews, check out Consumer Reports’ Best Toasters of 2025 and Bon Appétit’s guide.
Looking to upgrade more than just your toaster? Explore our picks for the top 10 portable projectors for on-the-go entertainment in 2025 and top 10 wireless earbuds to buy in 2025.
Happy toasting!