Grubhub vs. DoorDash: Which Food Delivery Service is More Affordable?

A split-screen image showing Grubhub and DoorDash logos with a background of various food items and a price tag symbol in the center.

Understanding Food Delivery Services

In today's fast-paced world, food delivery services have become an essential part of our daily lives. Among the most popular platforms are Grubhub and DoorDash, both offering convenient access to a wide range of restaurants and cuisines.

Pricing Structure Comparison

Base Delivery Fees

  • DoorDash: $1.99 to $5.99
  • Grubhub: $2.49 to $7.99

Factors affecting delivery fees include:

  • Distance from restaurant
  • Current demand
  • Restaurant partnerships
  • Time of day

Service Fees and Additional Costs

DoorDash

  • Service fee: 10-11% of order subtotal
  • Small order fee: $2.50 for orders under $10
  • Peak pricing during high-demand periods

Grubhub

  • Service fee: 5-15% of order subtotal
  • Small order fee: varies by restaurant
  • Priority delivery option: additional $2-7

Subscription Services

DoorDash DashPass

  • $9.99 monthly
  • $0 delivery fees on orders over $12
  • Reduced service fees
  • Special member-only promotions

Grubhub+

  • $9.99 monthly
  • $0 delivery fees on orders over $12
  • Exclusive perks and rewards
  • 10% cashback on pickup orders

Price Comparison Example

For a $40 order from a restaurant 2 miles away:

Cost ComponentDoorDashGrubhub
Delivery Fee$3.99$4.49
Service Fee$4.00$3.20
Total Added Costs$7.99$7.69

Important note: Both platforms allow restaurants to set higher menu prices than their in-store prices to offset commission fees.

Promotions and Discounts

Both services frequently offer promotions and discounts:

  • First-time user discounts
  • Referral bonuses
  • Seasonal promotions
  • Special deals with partner restaurants

Check their respective Grubhub and DoorDash websites for current offers.

Money-Saving Tips

  1. Compare prices across both apps before ordering
  2. Look for promotional codes and special offers
  3. Consider subscription services if you order frequently
  4. Use pickup options to avoid delivery fees
  5. Order directly from restaurants when possible

Additional Considerations

  • Availability: Both services are widely available across the United States, but coverage can vary by city and region.
  • Restaurant Selection: The variety of restaurants can differ between platforms.
  • Delivery Time: Times vary based on demand, location, and restaurant preparation times.

Conclusion

The most affordable option ultimately depends on:

  • Your location
  • Order frequency
  • Restaurant selection
  • Available promotions
  • Subscription status

For occasional users, DoorDash often proves more economical due to its competitive promotional offerings. Regular users might find better value with Grubhub+, especially when combining delivery and pickup orders to maximize cashback benefits. To ensure the best deals, it's recommended to install both apps and compare prices before placing orders, as rates can fluctuate significantly based on various factors.